Monday, February 25, 2013

Hog Island Mysteries - Chapter 61


Chapter 61
Hog Island – 1972

“This is where the plot thickens, Doctor Bechant,” Slade continued. “From archival stuff we learned about the guy from his running shoes. We believe that he is Alvin Atkinson. At the time of his death, he was 25. He was married to Angelica, known professionally as Angel.”

Slade smiled at the frowns his words generated. “So, now let me tell you about one couple from Paradise Island. The almost-newly-wed Atkinsons. Briefly, Atkinson was the disenfranchised son of an up-town millionaire family. He was disowned because he married Angel, a stripper. Atkinson prided himself as a top-notch amateur photographer. The owner of Mons Venus in Queens, New York, said that, decades before, the club was called Saturn. The then owner allowed Atkinson to photograph his girls in exchange for some appropriate ones for advertising. Atkinson met and photographed Angel in the buff, in provocative poses. He sold many of her photos to some European Men’s Magazines. Angel heard he was rich and decided to marry him, only to learn he’d been disowned. So, we conjecture – again – that there was no love lost between them on Paradise Island.”

“So, how did he die?” Janus asked, a smirk on his face.

“Not yet, sir. Let me introduce you to couple number two - the Bensons. Boyton and Beatrice were also newlyweds. Actually it was an arranged marriage between two corporations. From my vetting of them, I would classify them as unloved and unloving nerds. After their week on the island, they were to embark on their honeymoon by ship to the Mediterranean, with their final destination being Sicily, where the Bensons had a manufacturing facility, supplying materiel to the Italian, Greek, and Spanish militaries. Supposedly Boyton was given the responsibility of running it.”

“Great! Now what happened?” Haggard asked as he fired up a second cigar.

“From one of my sources, which I shall identify shortly, I learned that Barbara was terrified of water and only went on the vacation at the urging of her parents. But Boyton was an avid canoeist, having qualified as an alternate for the singles 500 meter flatwater race in Los Angeles in 1932.

Now this is pure conjecture on my part. But I think it reads well and seems plausible. I think that Boyton got Beatrice into the canoe and were paddling around the island, just off Paradise Beach when the boat tipped. She fell into the water. As he tried to get her back into the canoe, Atkinson arrives to help. And here’s where the story gets a little bizarre. It’s my guess that Atkinson grabs for the bow rope but it wraps around his throat. That results in crushing his throat and that little bone in the neck.”

“Hyoid,” Marion said, writing furiously on the pages before her.

“Thank you,” he said, not glancing from his notes. “The boat pulls free of the rope. As Boyton is still struggling to get Beatrice into the boat, others arrive on the scene. Boyton is out of earshot. Atkinson is essentially dead but in waist deep water. Some grab the the free end of the rope, and loop it around Atkinson’s ankles, and drag his body ashore. Probably to the very spot his bones were found decades later. Dragging his body resulted in the bone abrasions, broken bones, and the chunk of rope that Marion found on his remains.”

“Interesting. Okay, who were the people?” Bechant’s pen was poised over his notebook.

“I’ll get to that shortly, Doc. When Boyton returns, he’s weeping. Beatrice, his dear wife of only a few weeks, and half the future of the conglomerate, has been swept to sea and the man who tried to help save her was dead. At this point we need a head count. The Eberhardts? They’re probably searching for a way off the island, probably by Rodriguez’ boat. That leaves Angel, Atkinson’s widow, Boyton, the Benson widower, and two other couples. Let’s talk a moment about them.

“The others are Cameron and Charlotte Carter and David and Darlene Dawson. The Dawsons? A first marriage for David, a second for Darlene, who has two children from her previous marriage.

“This may be hard to believe but I am certain that the Carters were my parents. According to my erstwhile assistant, I was probably conceived on the island. Darlene also had a child about nine months after Paradise. Her name was, and is, Marion.”

Simultaneous gasps ensued, with all eyes focusing on Marion. Bechant asked, “Is that true?” She nodded, keeping her eyes on the ledger before her.

“Marion has two older step-siblings – Toby Topper and Margaret Pinkerton. Correct? He said, looking directly at her. She again nodded, her eyes downcast.

“Perhaps this is an appropriate time to take a bio-break.”

“Hey, Dollar?” Haggard snorted. “I don’t think so. Everybody’s gonna hold their pee until I hear whether this story is gonna have an ending or what?”

“It does, Boss. I believe we – being the ladies and me - have discovered a most reliable eye-witness to the events I’ve presented. David Dawson was a well-known author and left behind dozens of notebooks, logs, diaries, and journals. Marion, your stepbrother, Tobias Topper - aka Elder Wise and probably a dozen other aliases - allowed me to rummage through the Dawson artifacts that he purloined from your father’s house. After hundreds of hours of reading, my volunteer aide and I uncovered this notebook.”

Slade extracted a bound school notebook dated September 1938. He handed it to Ashton. Without looking at it, she placed it next to her ledger.

Peculiar, Slade thought. As he looked down at his notes, he gave a half-smile. After a moment, he looked up at the group, at their puzzled expressions.

“The notebook is a typical writer’s journal, chock full of words and phrases. But Mister Dawson also loved to observe people. And that’s where our interest peaks – beginning after Labor Day, 1938 and continuing to for some time after the Dawson’s stay on Paradise. In your packet I’ve provided you with copies of Mister Dawson’s journal beginning around the 9th of September and continuing for a little more than a week.

“Let me summarize the events this way. According to Dawson, there was substantial… let us say… hanky-panky on the island. Hanky-panky that involved three couples – the Atkinsons, the Dawsons, and the Carters. Yes, my folks were included as were Miss Ashton’s. Again according to Dawson, Mister Atkinson was somewhat of a gigalo. Although he wasn’t a very big man, his manner and outstanding good looks apparently attracted women. An Adonis, Dawson said the women – especially my mother and Marion’s -  called him.”

“I object, Dollar. Your insinuations are vulgar, obscene!” Marion yelled, slamming the journal hard on the table.

“Don’t be too judgmental, Marion. Because you and I were born only a few days apart, we might very well be kissin’ cousins. Or even brother and sister,” he snapped. “It seems that the islanders found a cache of first-class wine and imbibed and imbibed and imbibed some more. And after that, there was sex. Your father called it a world-class bacchanal.”

Those words hit her like a rock. She dropped back in her chair, glaring at him. Slowly her expression softened. “I’m sorry, Slade. It’s just that all of this…”

“…comes as a blow to the gut. Yeah. It hit me the same way.” Slade pulled out another folder. “According to the local papers, because the Paradise shuttle was sunk in the storm, the evacuation of the tourists from Hog Island was helter-skelter. As a result, there is no record of who was actually on the island just prior to the storm, who was rescued, and who was missing. What we do know is that Mister and Missus Benson caught their ship to Italy in Miami exactly three days later.”

“Wait!” Bechant said. “I thought that…”

“You thought correctly, Doc.” Slade interrupted. He pulled a newspaper page from yet another folder and held it up. “You are looking at a photograph of Mister and Missus Benson at a New Year’s Eve cocktail party in Salermo. The date? December 31st, 1938. If you look in your folder at that page and at the two inset photographs - the one on the left being that of Angel, the stripper, and the one on the right being Beatrice Barbato Benson nee Barone – it is apparent that the new Missus Benson who arrived on the island on the arm of Boyton Benson at Tiki Town, Paradise Island on the 10th of September was not the Missus Benson who was at the party in Italy a little over three months later.”

“Wait, Slade…” Haggard’s bravado had melted into a serious ponder. “Are you saying that the stripper was really Missus Benson?”

“No, boss. The real Missus Benson was in the boat that disappeared from Hog Island only to be beached on the neighboring barrier island. Keep in mind, Atkinson had lost his inheritance but Boyton still had his. Atkinson was dead and apparently so was Beatrice. Angel immediately realized that milquetoast Boyton was her next money source. She convinced him to leave with her. She found Beatrice’s passport and the ship line tickets and the two sailed away to Italy to live happily everafter, or at least happily for her. Ergo, the two Missus Bensons.

“You mean nobody objected to that?” Ashton asked. “And nobody reported the death of Atkinson and that Beatrice was missing?”

“The cop was dead, the agent was dead, the Germans had - for whatever reason - apparently fled. The storm scattered everybody, and I guess it was prudent for everybody to find their own way home. Marion’s father wrote weeks later, around the end of September, 1938, that six people survived the storm. He and his wife found each other in Bridgeport. They took a train to Manhattan where they were again met by the storm, this time destroying their home on Staten Island.”

And where were your parents all this time?” Marion asked snidely.

“Dunno. But my gramma told me that after the Hurricane, we moved to New Jersey. My dad opened a law office in Newark. Mom and dad were killed on the Jersey Turnpike when I was 5 or 6.”

“Anyway, back to your father. He spent several months researching the Paradise Island issue but never learned of the fate of the others. Nor did anyone bother to ask. No one in authority, no one from the hosting company, and certainly no curious news reporters. His last entry was after midnight on the 4th of July, 1939.”

“What was that entry?” Haggard said. He was now at full attention, unmindful that his cigar had extinguished itself at the edge of the conference table.

“I’m glad you asked,” Slade smiled. He pulled another page from his folder and read:

Anyway, I hear someone beginning the 4th early. After all, it is a little after 2 in the morning. Firecrackers. War on the horizon. With two kids and a third on the way, I should be at least 3A or something. But you never know. Heard recently that German U-boats were sighted off Atlantic coast.

Wonder if we’re safe here on Staten Island. Then again, why would anyone want to invade a 60 square mile island with fewer than 160,000 people and probably ten times that many hogs, chickens, cows, and sheep, when they can get all of Manhattan for just a few additional minutes boat ride.

And what about the gulf. Wonder about Paradise Island and that idiot Golden’s Tiki Town. Was it an outpost for German espionage? And I wonder about Darlene’s pregnancy too. Pediatrician guesses she conceived about that week. Bacchanalia?

“Oh, and chief? Here’s something for your archives.” Slade reached into his bag, extracted something, and rolled them across the table. “The two missing shell casings. Courtesy of Marion’s father.”

End of Chapter 61

End of Hog Island Mysteries

 

Hog Island Mysteries - Chapter 60


Chapter 60
Paradise Island – 1938

Mon, July 3rd, 0800 h
DW is as large as a house. Dr said this week or next for the great event. She can’t wait. I can. Her back’s been killing her. Her temper is killing me. Sometimes she says the weidest things, though. For example, yesterday she was talking about how her sister had so many issues when she was pregnant with twins. Darla has told me many times that she’s an only child.

Not looking forward to being the father of a new-born. Not at my age. And not with raising two kids from her first marriage. Drawing down my resources now. May need to get back to full-time brokering just to pay the medical bills. Toby and Margaret are eating me outa house and home. Growing kids, DW says. Yeah, I say, but why always the best food? My favorite food that for some reason disappears before I get to it?

Every time I complain that the soon-to-be five of us can’t live on a writer’s salary, she reminds me of the ‘treasure trove,’ as she calls it, of money I’d banked before I married her. We can always live on that, love, she’ll coo. Shit!

One of the top things on my agenda today is to clear away the detritus from my research on Paradise Island. I bought some cardboard boxes to store the stuff in. Up in the attic? Or maybe in the loft over the garage? Or maybe just at the curb for the trash guy. Well, before I decide that, I’ll make certain that I have all my notes in chronological order.

 Same, 1100 h
I’m not getting too far. I just finished rereading my Paradise Island log. Or as much of it as I had written before Memorial Day. So maybe I should finish the log before I pack up everything.

Lessee, I believe I’d left the ‘story’ when we all were huddled in the women’s toilet. I remember having one helluva headache from the tree branch or whatever. At times, double vision and at other times, blurred vision. And I remember Charlie cleaning and bandaging my head.

Somebody said the storm was abating and there was a sunrise. Meaning, I guess, that it was probably around 0700 h or so on Thursday, Sep 15th. My notes indicate that the first squalls were occurring nearly 24 h earlier. I remember Cameron saying that he was going to inspect the island and I recall asking him if I could go along. I’m sure that he shook his head no, pointing to my less-than-fit condition. Darla and Charlie volunteered to accompany him. I think Darla went with him because I remember that, while they were gone, Charlie redressed my gash.

I remember Cameron laying his shoulder into the door. Apparently sand had built up against it during the night. I think Darla and Cameron pushed and pushed, finally opening the door to the radiant glow of the morning sun. Hallelujah, someone said, reverently. The two exited only to have Cameron stick his head back into the room. ‘The wind is down and so are the waves,’ he said, grinning. ‘We’ll be back shortly,’ he yelled.

Apparently they were gone for more than just a few minutes. I was kinda dozing but I remember Charlie going to the door periodically. And yelling for them to answer.

Finally the two returned. ‘Bad news,’ Cameron said, slumping to the floor before the four of us. Darla moved to my side to sit. ‘There is very little left standing,’ he said. ‘The Tiki huts are ravaged. The utility building, with the kitchen, is stove in. The other side of this building, where the men’s toilet was, is caved in. The generator is leaning precariously against that very wall,’ he said, pointing to the wall we were all leaning against. ‘We tried to get to the dock,’ Darla said quietly, ‘but the path is blocked with huge palm trees and massive oak limbs.’

I remember the three – Darla, Charlie, and Cameron – discussing what to do next. They’d left me out of the conversation, thinking that I was too far out of it to participate. And they completely ignored Angel and Boyton, who were still huddled in the farthest reaches of the room. Their debate continued for several minutes. Or maybe a little longer. Finally, I recall stating in as clear a voice as possible, ‘bonfire.’

‘How,’ asked Cameron.

‘Generator diesel fuel,’ I said. Cameron’s eyes lit up.

‘I wonder,’ he said, ‘if we can access that tank.’

‘Tool shed,’ I remember saying.

He grinned. ‘You’re a genius, David. I remember seeing a pick in there.’

A half-hour later, the Carters and Darla had drained some of the generator fuel into a bucket, now empty of citronella. Cameron stuck his head in the door and said to me that when the generator tipped on its side, it uncovered some dry creosoted wood beams. ‘We’ve dragged these to where the commons once was and will pour the fuel on them. All we need are some matches,’ he said.

Angel perked up. ‘I’ve got some,’ she said. ‘And I think they’re dry.’

‘Come see, everybody,’ Darla chirped. ‘Paradise Island survivors are gonna have one last bonfire.’ With DW’s help, I managed to exit the toilet to sit on one of the few tree stumps that were still visible in the sand. Angelica had decided that Boyton should not see the devastation and so they remained huddled in the bathroom.

And so the fuel was lit. And what a fire it was, the creosoted beams generating huge clouds of smoke. I was certain that the flames and black smoke climbed a hundred feet into the morning sky. ‘Surely that should be seen from the mainland,’ Charlie said, alternately staring at the mainland and at the blazing bucket. We all hoped, silently, of course.

She said that the trio had prepared additional buckets, supposedly enough to keep the fire burning all day, if necessary. Cameron carried one of the buckets to Paradise beach and lit it there. By now the wind was calm and the air smelt like dead fish and salt.

I remembered seeing sand dunes banked a couple of yards high against the men’s toilet wall. Tiki Town was no more. A, C, and D huts were gone. Even the foundations were covered with sand. B hut had one wall standing. The roof and the other three walls were somewhere else. E hut, our last refuge before the women’s toilet, was free of a roof and the rear wall leaded crazily inward. I agreed with Carter that we would not have enjoyed our evening in E hut.

Darla and Charlie headed to what was left of the fridges and pantries. Most of the food in one of the fridges was spoiled. Cameron said that the door must have been sucked open by the wind. In the other fridge, the juices seemed okay. ‘A bit warm,’ Darla cautioned, ‘but apparently drinkable.’ Charlie had recovered a loaf of bread and some marmalade. She coaxed Angelica and Boyton from the refuge and the six of us ate our first meal in what? A few hours? A day?

I remember deciding that I was capable of walking, albeit with a crutch or a cane made of a sturdy tree branch. Maybe the same one that had clobbered me. I said I wanted to see the devastation first-hand. Particularly the dock area, I said, because it was our way in and would be the first place people would go when looking for us.

The sun was pretty high in the sky, maybe 1000 h or so, when the four of us – Angelica again stayed behind with Boyton – made our way to the dock. I remember thinking that Darla was right. The path was obliterated. We climbed over palm trees and oaks and worked our way around chunks of Tiki huts. The dock was essentially gone, absent, no longer there. Just some vertical posts that had at one time supported the dock deck.

After some discussion and disagreement, the Carters opted to climb the hill. Their thought was to signal to the mainland. Charlie had procured a piece of mirror from the women’s toilet. Darla and I returned to what was once Tiki Town, to stoke the bucket fire.

When we got back to the camp, Angelica was all smiles. Seems as though, she’d convinced Boyton to take her to Italy with him. DW related the following to me several days later. Darla was furious at the ‘brazen hussy.’ ‘How could she do that,’ she asked. ‘The man’s wife is dead. Doesn’t he understand that?’

Angel smiled again. ‘Of course he does,’ she said. ‘His family requires him to go to Italy, but because of his mental condition, he can’t do it without my help. So I volunteered to go along. To help him,’ she smiled an even wider grin.

‘Don’t you need a passport or something,’ DW asked.

‘Sure,’ she said, showing her Beatrice’s passport. It was damp, the edges were curled, and the photograph was smudged.

‘So, you are going to pretend you’re Missus Benson,’ DW asked.

‘Of course,’ Angelica laughed. ‘And maybe when we get to Italy, I’ll become the real Misses Benson.’

The Carters had returned an hour or so later. Charlie said that they could see across the sound from the top of the farmhouse. He said that it appeared that the harbor at Lewiston was awash in sunken boats. But he thought that they’d been able to signal for help. And of course, there was the bonfire which he said was easily visible from the farm and certainly would be seen in the town as well.

I remember asking Darla to help me down to Paradise Beach. Over her vociferous objections and those of the others, I prevailed. I had two objectives. First, I wanted to see the extent of the damage from the storm. In short, whether anyone from the mainland could beach their boat there. So she helped me wobble my way there.

To my shock, the huge tree root outcropping was gone! There was no sign that it had ever been there. The beach had been eroded by at least ten yards. I waded into the water to check the bottom. The water was frigid and there was a rapid drop-off a couple of yards from the water line. I deemed that launches from the mainland could beach successfully, but certainly not as easily as before the storm.

My second objective was to make certain that the wind, rain, and storm surge had not disturbed big Al’s grave site. But we couldn’t find it! Of course, the entire topography of the area had been rearranged. Even Darla couldn’t believe that we couldn’t find the site. After all, I remember her saying, we buried him right at the base of a huge oak tree next to a large area of underbrush growth. But it couldn’t’ve been because the area by what we thought was the oak tree was now completely devoid of any vegetation. Some distance away, near a smaller oak tree, we found the remains of the cross that Charlie had made. So we pushed and prodded the ground there. Again without success.

After what seemed like forever – probably sometime early afternoon - we abandoned our search and returned to the campsite to relate our findings. Or lack thereof. Cameron thought that the storm surge had swept Al’s body out to sea and filled in the grave with sand. The four of us – Darla, Charlie, Cameron, and me – had been busy reconstructing the timeline of the storm when we heard Angelica yell that she had heard a motor. A boat motor.

Should someone go down to the dock to tell them where we are, she asked. They’ll find us, Cameron assured. After all, the bonfire is here at the camp, not at the dock or the farm, he said. And besides, I lit another citronella pail of fuel oil down at the beach just as we were leaving there. Sure enough, about 15 min later, a putt-putt flat-bottomed scow beached at Paradise Beach. Two men, both in their late sixties or early seventies, waded ashore.

They said that they’d come from Bridgeport to see if they could help the boaters in Lewiston. On their way, they saw the smoke plume and decided to investigate. They were shocked when they learned that there were people on the island. And even more shocked when they learned there were six of us who had braved the storm. Although braving I don’t think is a proper word for what we all did.

Tim, the boat owner, said that he could take only two. And they would try to dock at Lewiston but if the wharf was as badly damaged as another boater had said, they’d head back to Bridgeport.

We’d decided that Boyton and Angelica be the first off the island. It was apparent that Boyton was in need of some medical attention, maybe even some mental reorientation. And since Angelica had taken him under her wing, so to speak, we thought it only proper that they go first. So, as the two men helped Boyton into the skiff, Angelica gathered up what few goods she’d rescued. Once Boyton was seated, they helped her in and putt-putted away, yelling back that they’d send other launches for us as soon as they got to port.

Around 1600 h, the same launch returned. They told us that they’d off-loaded the other couple in Lewiston and they were planning on doing the same with the next couple. The Carters were the next to leave. Charlie argued that because my gash needed medical treatment, I should go with Cameron and she’d stay with Darla. I argued that Darla and I would leave together. Everybody hugged everybody else and vowed to meet again, on the mainland.

Twenty minutes later, a small power boat beached itself. ‘Cap’n Jensen, at your service,’ the old geezer said as he waded ashore. ‘I jes came over from Bridgeport ta see what all the excitement’s about. I see’s there’s two of ya. Kin only take one. Be back for you sir.’

A couple of minutes later, over DW’s violent objections, he and DW putt-putted away in Linger Longer, the name of his 10 foot ‘yacht.’ My guess is that it was noon, maybe a little later.     

I waited. And waited. And waited. I remember thinking that I’ve been forgotten. A Robinson Caruso without a Friday. The sun was arcing toward the water when I heard Cap’n Jensen holler for me. ‘Thought I’d forgotten ya,’ he laughed, showing mostly gaps in the bottom row of teeth. ‘Hadda get gas, y’know. Wait in line. Couldn’t put in at Lewiston, tho. Side of the wharf jes’ collapsed under the weight of a rescue vehicle. Ya ready? I tol’ yer missus that I was gonna git’cha an’ that she oughta wait right at the Bridgeport pier fer ya. Or what’s kinda left of the wharf,’ he snickered.

I was ready. I had my knapsack in hand and started toward the water’s edge when I spotted something a yard away. It was Al’s camera case. Angelica must have put it down to get into the boat and then forgotten it. So now it was mine.

It was nearly 1900 and almost dark when Jensen tied up to what was left of the Bridgeport pier. The Lewiston wharf was – or had been - wood. The Bridgeport pier was concrete. Even so, a huge section of concrete was tilted at a thirty-degree angle with one end below the water line. Someone had fastened a wood extension ladder to the slope and a couple of men in uniform grabbed my shirt and hoisted me up the three feet between the boat and the wharf deck. It seemed that what was left of the wharf was a triage area. People were arrayed on pallets along the back edge of the wharf where they were being attended by medics and first responders and volunteers carrying first aid kits. Someone was rigging some battery-operated lights and everywhere I remember hearing people calling out names and words like stat.

I was still having vision problems and managed to compensate by holding my hand over my left eye. Someone asked me to please move away from the wharf as others were trying to access the ladder. I did so, trying to peer through the crush of people for Darla. She found me first. I remember she laughed that she recognized the Paradise Island logo on the towel I had around me. We hugged and kissed and giggled and hugged and kissed some more.

She said she’d been waiting for me forever. We looked at each other and laughed, simultaneously. We were two disheveled prisoners of Paradise. Before we’d abandoned our Tiki hut, she’d been smart to have changed into slacks and a rather heavy long-sleeved shirt. However, her shoes were just not made for walking. They were essentially trashed. Me? I’d wore my standard heavy shirt, heavy slacks, my special one-of-a-kind alligator boots, and my bush hat. My shirt and slacks were shredded and my boots and hat were sodden.

I remember her saying that she was so worried that I wouldn’t be rescued but that the old geezer had assured her that he’d find me. She focused on my face, my forehead, and I think she said that my bandage was seeping blood. A woman in what I think was a Red Cross uniform saw me weaving on Darla’s arm and asked what my problem was. Darla pointed to my head and told her that I had taken a very hard knock. The woman handed Darla a sheaf of forms to fill out. She scribbled her way through them. Under ‘injuries,’ she wrote ‘head trauma.’ The woman had disappeared into the ebbing and flowing humanity. So we waited, and waited, and waited. In reality, I really was still woozy. Leaning forward helped. I recall someone shaking me, asking me if I was okay. You were asleep for at least an hour,’ the same woman in the same uniform said. Darla handed her the papers and she departed back into the human surge.

A few minutes later, a medic - I can’t recall his name – examined me top and bottom, but spent most of his time concentrating on my vision and balance. ‘MTBI,’ he said. ‘Plus a huge hematoma to the forehead.’ I remember asking him what MTBI was. He sniffed before reeling off ‘mild traumatic brain injury.’

‘Serious,’ I asked. ‘Could be,’ he said. He rattled off a whole bunch of questioning words. Nauseated? Double vision? Headache? Loss of cognitivity or fuzziness?’

Of course, I had all of these but I answered no to each one. My objective right at that moment was to get us the hell away from that location. So, the medic scribbled something on his form, proceeded to reclean and rebandage the wound, and without another word, disappeared into the melee in the same direction as the Red Cross lady.

I recall that it was getting far into the night. I asked Darla if any of the other survivors were here. She said she hadn’t seen any of them but they may have been taken to Lewiston. ‘So what do we do,’ I asked. She said that we needed to find our way back home. Somehow. I remember her saying that she didn’t have any money in her purse. I laughed and said I had some. I pulled a cellophane bag out of my backpack and handed it to her. I’d stashed a couple hundred dollars, in tens, in there. Just in case.

I guess it was a few minutes later when a very official-looking gentleman, accompanied by a couple of cops, stopped where we were sitting. He asked who we were. We gave him our names. I thought he was going to write them onto the clipboard he was carrying but he didn’t.

He asked how we’d got here. Darla said that we’d been vacationing on a barrier island when the storm came up. When he said Lulu, she just shrugged but frowned at me. Before I could say anything to refute that, he jotted something on the clipboard.

He was about to leave when I told him we were tourists and that we needed to get back to New York City. I asked him about the airport. He said that the airport had been destroyed, but we might be able to catch a train from Alice, a town about twenty miles inland. The next northbound train was due in the early afternoon or so, he said. When I asked him how we could get to Alice, one of the cops said that his brother could take us. For a fee. ‘How much,’ DW asked. ‘Twenty bucks,’ he said.

A half hour later, the cop’s brother – I never did get his name – deposited us at the Alice train station, an ersatz Victorian with a tiny waiting room and a very short waiting platform. Surprisingly, although Bridgeport seemed to have suffered substantial damage – missing roofs, bent lampposts, debris scattered everywhere – Alice seemed to have been mostly spared the ravages of what was now known as the ‘no-name storm.’ A few tree branches, some wires down. At least that was what we could see as we came into the tiny hamlet.

When we asked the cop’s brother where we could stay for the night, he pointed to a small but very neat Victorian home across the street from the station. It turned out that the place – Gloria’s Retreat – was a nursing home. After Miss Gloria Sebastian, the proprietress, heard our plight, she welcomed us in. She said that she’d get us something to eat while we were taking hot showers. And she insisted that we stay the night in the front parlor. On a Murphy bed. She handed us a couple of terry robes and said that she’d wash our clothes. Darla pointed to what had been quality duds but were now mostly rags, and laughed that they weren’t worth washing. Miss Gloria said that while we were showering she’d see if she could find us more suitable clothes.

That evening, we had beef and barley stew, hot tea, and lemon sugar cookies. And true to her word, Miss Gloria found us some apparel that, believe it or not, mostly fit. She even found a suitable pair of shoes for Darla. When DW asked her about their origins, she laughed and said that some of her roomers, both men and women, would skip out without paying. So she’d keep the clothes. ‘Just in case,’ she laughed, ‘someone would come along who needed them.’

It was long after ten by then. Darla and I had, a long time before, reached the simultaneous yawning stage. We begged to head to the Murphy bed. And it was probably only five minutes later that we were asleep, buried under one of the most comfortable comforters I’ve ever slept under.

It was nearly ten the next morning when I awoke. Startled. I remember bolting up in bed and frantically searching the room and listening for, what? The sound of rain? Wind? I’m sure it only took me a couple of minutes to sufficiently calm myself, but it seemed like an eternity. I did my toilet and was dressing when Darla finally began to stir. And I was sitting at Miss Gloria’s table, having a second cheese Danish and a second cup of coffee when she arrived, looking really the worse for wear.

While she was having her breakfast, I moseyed to the train station and purchased tickets all the way through to New York City. The train was scheduled to arrive precisely at one-thirty-five at a cost of sixty-five dollars each. Now you ask how I know all this? Well, I’m sitting here with all that information in my hand, on one of the ticket stubs DW kept.

Even though we’d had a late breakfast, Miss Gloria insisted that we have lunch as well. Finally, after much toing-and-froing, Darla convinced her that perhaps she could just make us some sandwiches. For the train. Which she did, packing them in an oversized wicker picnic basket. I could barely wrestle it on board the train and when we opened it – in Atlanta, where the stop was more than an hour – we found half-a-dozen turkey and roast beef sandwiches, two chicken legs, a dozen each of chocolate chip and sugar cookies, a thermos of coffee, and two quart bottles of lemonade. How do I know this inventory? Because I marked it down on the back of one of my typewriter pages. As it turned out, Miss Gloria’s extra food was welcomed over the next few days.

And after that sumptuous repast, we slept. A porter woke us as the train inched into the 42nd Street station, then directed us to the Sheraton Russell Hotel a few blocks away. It was fortunate that they had just one double room left. And even more fortunate, that they would accept a personal check for the room.

As it turned out, we ended the Paradise Island saga just in time to start the Staten Island devastation saga a couple of days later. 

Same, ~2400 h
Well, tomorrow is July 4th. Time to put away everything about Paradise Island. I’ll make certain that I add in these last few pages.

Interesting. I was just sorting through the papers and detritus – things like tickets and newspaper articles and even a brochure touting Paradise Island – when I came upon a small manila envelope. One with the metal fold-down tags. Across the front was written: AL’S PHOTOS. In all the confusion of being rescued from the island and then finding that our home had been destroyed by the same storm, I’d forgotten completely Al’s camera bag and its contents that resided in the bottom of my rucksack. When life began to return to normality in May, I’d cleaned out my bag, found the camera bag, and had simply set it aside. For a future look-see, I thought. If they are photos of the women in all their birthday suits, I’ll trash them. But only after I have a good ogle. A remembrance of that bacchanalia night. Or at least the little bit that I can remember. 

July 4th, ~0200 h
I just reread the entire log, including these last few pages. I made some annotations and addenda here and there. Nothing of any great value, however. At one time – I think it was while we were waiting out the storm, fearful for our lives, to be exact – I thought that the log might provide me with a basis for a fanciful who-dunnit. But after rereading it and wondering if I should just deep-six the entire thing, I’ve decided that the best thing would be to put it all away. Just like I said a couple of hours ago. 

Same, a few minutes later
Y’know, it’s pretty hard to put this down. I mean in those few days ten months ago, our life spun completely out of control, and it has taken us months to try to regain some control back. Seriously, I worry about Darla. Every once in a while, she’ll blurt out some strange story about Paradise Island. A couple of weeks ago, she asked me if I remembered a red-haired boy with a twisted leg. When I said no, she laughed. ‘Why he always looked in our cabin window while we were having sex in bed,’ she said. I assured her that it was all her imagination. I am quite concerned that the events of those few days pray on her mind far more than just these fanciful stories.

Funny, we never heard from any of the others. I’m pretty sure Angelica got away with pretending to be Boyton’s spouse. Hey, from stripper to CEO arm candy is a pretty good jump if you get my drift. They’re probably ensconced in some Italian villa right about now, eating ghiacchio Italiano or some such delicacy.

Even more surprising is that we never heard from the Carters. Pretty sure they made it ashore. A really nice couple. Can’t remember where they were from, except that I think he said he was a Manhattan lawyer. Around the end of last year, I decided to keep the office open. When the rent began to outstrip the income, I closed it the end of May. I dug out Cameron Carter’s law office address but his law firm had relocated elsewhere. The current folks wouldn’t tell me where, though. Maybe someday, I’ll check with the City Legal Department to see where he went.

And of course, whatever happened to the couple in the E hut? Never saw them. Maybe they didn’t exist. Maybe they were killed on the island, in all that gunfire. Or maybe, as Darla said one night a couple of months back, a German submarine plucked them from Paradise. She was serious.

As I said, the September 21st hurricane that devastated Staten Island and totally undid our world took precedent over any and all of the Paradise Island events. Nevertheless, sitting here nearly a year from the event, I wonder whether anyone ever tried to learn what happened to us five couples. For example, I wonder if anyone found the bodies of Al and Beatrice? I scoured the papers from that area ahead ‘til the end of ’38 with nary a mention of finding their bodies. According to the Manhattan Main Library archives, the Lewiston newspaper said that the storm killed thirty-five people in the Lewiston, including several fishermen and Buster, the skipper of the Paradise launch. What was his name again? Butch, Buster? But there was no mention of Paradise Island bodies or even of us, the survivors.

What is even odder is that nobody ever came asking about the details of Paradise Island. Or about the gunshots or shell casings. And nobody asked for a head count of the people on the island, before or after the storm. I mean, I would’ve thought that someone would’ve wanted to know why five couples went to the island and only three returned. But maybe nobody knew that anyone had returned. Maybe we’re all presumed dead. Or more probably, nobody knew that there were people on the island before, during and after the storm.

I tried to contact the Paradise Company without success. I wonder if the Paradise Company records were destroyed in the storm. Certainly, according to the local paper, their launch was. And that’s why nobody official came to save us. Only the armada of curious boaters. And thank God for them.

End of Chapter 60

 

Hog Island Mysteries - Chapter 59


Chapter 59
Hog Island – 1972 

“Thank you all for coming. As you know, the purpose of this meeting is to review the findings on what we here call the Hog Island Murders. I hope we can conclude this meeting in plenty of time to get where we need to be for the upcoming weekend celebrations.”     

It was after ten the Friday before Father’s Day weekend. Slade was standing at the head of the Lewiston Police Station Conference Room table, in the spot normally reserved for his boss. Haggard was unaccustomed to sitting at the foot of the table but that was precisely where he was this morning. Anne was there, her steno pad at the ready. Dowdy was there too, as was Marion Ashton and Doctor James Bechant. Captain Janus from the State Highway Patrol and one of his deputies, Lieutenant Jameson were sitting across from the SCSI team. Desk Sergeant Griff was at his post, but had swiveled his chair around to observe the meeting. And in the corner, behind the SCSI group sat two of Dollar’s ladies, Kaitlyn Murphy and Madeline Patterson, firing daggers at one another.

“My boss,” he started, nodding to Haggard at the end of the table, an unlit cigar clenched in his teeth. “My boss gave me an ultimatum to wrap up the case before Father’s Day. I hope this meeting will go most of the way toward doing so. Let me begin by thanking people who have in great measure assisted me on this venture. Miss Murphy, Bridgeport Librarian, was responsible for ferreting out backgrounds of those who vacationed on the island. Obituaries on those who died there, as well.

“Miss Ashton was perceptive enough to read into the remains of our victims clues that became important talismen to the case. Miss Patterson, Miss Ashton’s best friend forever, diligently put together the final pieces of the puzzle. And finally Professor Bethany Lightner, who found names and addresses of many of the people who were present the week of the no-name storm. Unfortunately Miss Lightner declined my offer to appear today to accept my accolades.”

“C’mon, Dollar. Get the goddamned show on the road, ferchrissakes!” Haggard snorted as he fired up his stogie.

          “Right on, Boss. But before we get started, Patrolman Dowdy and Sergeant Griff? I forgot the blackboard in my office. I hate to ask but could you bring it down for us?”

Slade waited until the two had plodded toward the stairs to say, “While we wait, why don’t you all grab a coffee or a juice? And a roll or donut? They’re on the back table, courtesy of Aunt Bea who opened especially for this occasion.”

* * *

After the men had placed the blackboard behind Slade, he called the meeting back to order. “I’m not going to go into detail about all the aspects of the last week on Paradise Island. I’ll just hit the highlights. But let me start this way. Over the last two weeks, Miss Patterson volunteered to help me sort out the details. This was after Chief Haggard nixed my request for paid help. It was in casual conversation that we finally were able to piece together the scenario of the last days of Paradise Island.

          “Initially, much of the story that I am about to tell was based on conjecture. In short, guess. But recent input, which I will describe later, has convinced us that the story is pretty much factual. Let’s begin with the characters on the island.”

“Let’s not, Dollar!” Haggard sneered.

“I second that!” Captain Janus echoed.

“Okay…” Slade leafed through a few pages before pointing to the blackboard. “I’ll identify them as I go along.

“As you can see…” Slade touched the long wood pointer to locations on the board. “…the X’s are where three bodies were found. You will also see two arrows off the edge of the board. I’ll explain these as I go along. The squares are where the five Tiki huts were located. I’ve lettered them A through E. The old DeBoer farmhouse and barn are indicated by the elongated oval. I’ve also drawn in some lines. These represent paths from various locations. As you see, they are numbered.”

“Are we supposed to study these, or what?” Haggard asked, the smoke from his cigar now forming a grayish-blue fog between him and Dollar. “’Cause frankly I can’t see a goddamned thing from here.”

“I am delighted you asked. In front of you, sir, is a folder. If you will open it, you will see an 8 x 10 photo of the blackboard. If you turn to the next several pages, you will see close-ups of various portions of my drawing. If there are no other questions, I’d like to proceed.”

He immediately proceeded without waiting for further questions. “First, I want to concentrate not on the people who were vacationing at Tiki Town, but on the others who were not. They are Chester Monroe, State Highway Patrolman, whose remains were found here.” Slade touched the X behind Tiki Hut E.

“Mario Rodriguez, Federal Special Agent, whose remains were found here.” He touched the X inside the vertical oval.

“And Lars deBoer, whose remains were found at Bayport. Insofar as we’ve been able to determine, there was only one weapon between the three of them. It was a 38-caliber Police Special, registered to Patrolman Monroe.

“Correct me if I am wrong, Dr. Bechant, But according to your staff at SCSI, Monroe was wounded in the shoulder with a round from that weapon. Your people believe that Monroe could not have shot himself. The round from that that weapon was found in the vicinity of Monroe’s remains, here.” Slade pointed again to the area behind Tiki Hut E.

“Furthermore, we found two shell casings at the foot of the stairs to the second floor of the old deBoer farmhouse, here.” He tapped his pointer at the outline of the farmhouse.

“From SCSI ballistics report, the shell casings matched the casings of the rounds that remained in the weapon. The weapon was found in the vicinity of Rodriguez’ body, here.” He pointed to the outline of the barn.

“After careful reading of the SCSI report, we learned that only two bullets remained in the weapon, meaning that four were discharged.

“Now comes some sleuthing. According to Miss Ashton’s finely detailed forensic autopsy report…” Slade extracted it from the pile of folders before him. “Monroe was apparently shot while he and the shooter were on the same level. Standing, perhaps.

“On the other hand, from Doctor Bechant’s report on the remains of Mister DeBoer indicates that the wound in the victim’s left leg was due to a projectile that entered low and rose as it passed through the bone. Recall that the two shell casings were found at the foot of stairs. I surmise that whoever pulled the trigger shot Mister DeBoer as he was standing on or descending the stairs but shot Patrolman Monroe as he was standing on the same level as the shooter.”

“Where are the other two shell casings, Dollar?” Haggard snorted.

“Perhaps I can address your question a little later. If that’s okay with you?”

Haggard shrugged and blew another blue-gray cloud of cigar smoke into the air. At which point Captain Janus said in a half-joking voice, “Are you really sure about all this, Dollar?”

Slade glared at the officer. “Please let me continue, hopefully to an answer to your derogatory question, sir.”

Before Janus could rebut him, he continued. “While Miss Patterson and I were on the island, attempting to reenact the shooting sequence, she spotted something in the second floor window of the farmhouse. I climbed what was left of the stairs and grabbed this.” Slade extracted an evidence bag containing the long-lens binoculars.

“These are military issue binoculars, manufactured around 1934. In Germany. And sold only in Germany. Whoever had been using these was focusing on activities west of Hog Island. In the Gulf. And I believer that whoever had been using these for whatever purpose had been startled by activity on the floor below. Otherwise that person would not have abandoned this very expensive equipment.”

“So it was the deBoer kid, right?” Haggard asked sarcastically.

“No. Lars deBoer was lame and medically considered mentally deficient. He had a tested IQ of no more than 60 and probably a good deal less. Not a good candidate to be an espionage agent, right, boss?”

When Haggard shrugged a reply, Slade continued. “So where does this lead us? Directly to Emil and Emma Eberhardt, recently arrived from Germany. Berlin, to be exact.” Dollar extracted a sheaf of paper from his case and placed it atop the other papers. “Both Eberhardts were arrested sometime later for espionage activities. After extensive interrogation by the Canadian Mounted Police, Emil was deported.” Slade held up a rather thick folder. “Emma, claiming diplomatic immunity, was released back to Germany by the United States.” He held up a second folder.

“Now, my volunteer aide and I asked ourselves: Why was at least one of the Eberhardts – perhaps Emma - on the island?”

“Wait, Slade,” Dowdy asked, his face screwed into an odd question mark pose. “Why Emma?”

“Good question, Larry. I’ll get to that shortly. Lemme return to my redundant question. Most obvious answer: The deBoer house had the highest elevation of all the local barrier islands. And a clear nearly one-eighty view of the gulf.

“It is our opinion that four or five people wound up at the same place at the same time. Here’s our conjecture. Monroe was on standard patrol, having left his partner on Lulu Island. He putt-putted and beached his boat to what the Paradise Corporation called Sunset Beach. According to State Patrol records, the Paradise Island Tiki Town was well-known to both them and other law enforcement officials.

So it would make no sense for Monroe to be checking on or covertly observing the Tiki people. Instead he headed directly toward the farm buildings. At about that time, Agent Rodriguez, who may have come ashore in some manner on the other side of the island, was stalking one of the Eberhardts, probably Emil. As I said, I believe that Emma, not Emil, was at the second floor window with his binocs. Rodriguez probably entered the house on cat’s paws, not wanting to spook the spy. Just about then, Monroe arrived, saw Rodriguez, and, not knowing what Rodriguez was doing on the island, unholstered his weapon and attempted to arrest him. Probably for trespassing.

“The two scuffled. I believe that Rodriguez grabbed Monroe’s gun. It may have gone off accidentally, the round hitting Monroe in the shoulder. The ruckus spooked Eberhardt, who came to the top of the stairs just as Lars, who had been living in an upstairs back room, pushed past him and started down the stairs. Rodriguez fired, attempting to hit Eberhardt, but instead hit Lars in the leg. Lars may have fallen down the stairs atop Rodriguez. We guess that Eberhardt pushed past the two and headed out the door. Rodriguez ran after him, perhaps firing at him as he went.

“The next scenario is quite iffy,” Slade said.

Haggard and Janus roared, simultaneously. “You bet your sweet ass, Dollar,” Haggard snorted. “But it sure ain’t any more iffy that what we’ve heard so far.”

Dollar, his face in an intense frown, looked over his reading glasses at Haggard. He was about to call his boss down, but decided against it. Instead, he continued. “Eberhardt headed for the barn.” He pointed to a point in the oval. “She hid inside. When Rodriguez bolted in, Eberhardt probably cold-cocked him with a chunk of wood or a rock. That caused him to fall back into the wall of the barn which immediately collapsed onto him. That, we believe, is why the weapon was found with Rodriguez, under the wall.

“If you’ll recall, Miss Ashton, you pointed out two impact areas on Rodriguez’ skeleton. One was what you called ‘blunt trauma impact’ to his skull. Perhaps where Emma whacked him with a beam or a rock. Another was pelvis fracture. Where the falling wall crushed him. He probably didn’t die of either trauma but of starvation or suffocation. Of course, we’ll never know, will we?

“We believe that Patrolman Monroe was bleeding badly but made it back to Tiki Town. But the only person there – again supposition – was Emil Eberhardt. After begging him for help, he collapsed from loss of blood. He clubbed Monroe to death with a shovel. When Emma returned, still wearing her bedroom slippers, the two buried Rodriguez behind their hut, here.” Slade pointed to the hut marked ‘E.’

“Meanwhile, Lars, probably bleeding profusely from the gunshot that fractured his leg, made his way to Sunset Beach, where he found the Police launch. He pushed it off the sand and into the water, climbed into it, probably tried to start the motor but collapsed from loss of blood, and was swept away by the incoming storm. When the launch capsized at Bayport, he was trapped under it. And that’s precisely where the launch and his remains were found a couple of months ago.”

“Okay. That’s a pretty good conjecture,” Bechant said. “But what about the guy in the running shoes? And the lady on the other barrier island? Are those people part of the intrigue on Hog Island?”

“It would seem so. But I believe that the two incidents that occurred on the island were contemporary and therefore connected only by happenstance.”

“Proof?” Haggard chuckled.

“It’s coming shortly, boss. Shortly.”

End of Chapter 59

 

Hog Island Mysteries - Chapter 57


Chapter 57
Hog Island – 1972

It was a beautiful late Spring morning. The two had finished their early morning swim and had ridden the Y stationary bikes for half-an-hour and were now sitting in Malberg Park, coffees in hand.

“Y’know, Slade, I’m beginning to enjoy the South. Everybody’s so laid back and friendly. In Boston, everybody’s in everybody else’s faces, if you know what I mean.”

“Well, if your Boss’s wish comes true, and if he makes good on his offer to you, we’ll be kissin’ cousins, as you said. I mean, that site is only about 20 miles from here.” He opted against saying any more.

“Did you ever tell me your family history?” she asked.

“No. Why?”

“Were you born in this part of the country?”

“No. My parents lived on Staten Island. My dad was a lawyer. Patent law. He worked in Manhattan. My mother was an actress. Mostly Broadway and off-Broadway stage. My grandmother, her mother, said she’d been raped by a football player she was dating. One of dad’s partners was her lawyer in the case. Put the guy away for twenty or so. My dad met her, they married, she got pregnant with me, and became a stay-at-home mom. In 1955, we were on the New Jersey Turnpike. Heavy smoke. The car was rear-ended by a truck. The car was driven under a truck trailer. Report said my parents died instantly. Decapitated. I was just six and slid from the back seat to the floor where they found me screaming and hollering hours later. With my mother’s head in my lap.”

“My God,” she gasped. After what seemed an eternity, she said, “Slade, what were your parents’ names?”

“Cameron and Charlotte. Except she went by the nickname ‘Charlie.’”

“Cameron and Charlotte Dollar,” she said to herself, trying to force the names into her memory.

“No. Cameron and Charlotte Carter. My grandparents on my mother’s side adopted me. Their name was Dollar, so that’s mine too. Sorta like John Jacob Jingleheimer Smith.”

“Who?” she laughed.

“Never heard of John Jacob Jingleheimer Smith?” He sung the words.

“Nope. And hope I don’t need to,” she laughed again.

“My gramma’s favorite jingle. I’ll sing it to your kids. When and if you have any.”

“No fear on that! Had mumps when I was a teenager. Rendered me sterile.”

“Sorry to hear that. Well, maybe you can adopt some.”

“Good thought. But no. Back to your parents and your grandparents. Are they still living?”

“No. Grampa died about ten years ago. Gramma died two years ago. So, I’m now officially an orphan. An adult one, but still an orphan.”

“Enough about me. What about you? What was your maiden name?”

“Wait a minute, Slade.” Suddenly her face scrolled into a deep frown. “You identified all the people on the island, right?”

“Yeah…” He was startled by her change of expression. “Why?”

“Did you fully vet all of them?”

“No. Never was able to find the C’s and I’m still not too sure about Missus B. Why?”

“What was the name of the C’s?”

“Crater.”

“First names?”

“None given. Just initials. ‘C and C Crater.’”

“Slade, what if the last name was misspelled? Suppose it was Carter, not Crater. Would that make a difference?”

Slade’s mouth dropped open and he paled to the point where Madeline was concerned that he was about to pass out. “Jesus,” he muttered. “You don’t suppose…”

“Where were the Craters from?”

“Staten Island,” he said, weakly.

“Maybe that’s why you couldn’t find the Craters, Slade. They misspelled your parents’ names. The C’s were Cameron and Charlotte Carter.”

          “My God,” he said, leaning back against the chair. “My own parents were on the island. They must’ve won the prize. My God…”

“Ah, Slade? When’s your birthday?”

“July 10th, why?”

She began counting on her fingers. “Female gestation is about 40 weeks. According to my less-than-exact calculation, you were conceived mid-September, 1938.”

When Slade just sat there, his mouth agape, she smiled. “Slade, cheer up. You’re a Tiki Town baby!”

“Well, worse things coulda happened.”

“Like?”

“Like not being born at all!” he laughed, trying to break through his confliction. “Just think, Madeline, if that hadn’t happen, you wouldn’t’ve met such a nice guy like me!”

She laughed, leaned on his shoulder, and kissed him on the cheek. “Y’know, Slade, that was the nicest thing anybody ever said to me.”

Abruptly, he stood and offered his hand to her. “C’mon. Gold’s is waiting.”

“But,” she protested. “I thought we’ve done enough today. I mean, I’m really tired, Slade!”

“Okay. A better idea. How about one of Aunt Bea’s Supershakes?”

“Yeah!” she bounced up and grabbed his hand. “That’s more like it!”
  
* * *
             They finished the day by collecting her ‘stuff’ from the Holiday Inn. They shopped for groceries and she baked them a Shepherd’s Pie for dinner. After a rough and tumble night, they dined on toast and jam and coffee and returned to the park where they held hands and drank more coffee. On a whim, they headed over Telegraph Hill to the Lewiston Historical Museum and Gift Shop, housed in an early 20th century pseudo-Victorian home, now declared the Wilford Mansion, after the Wilfords who supposedly had settled the area after the civil war. But who had never owned a pseudo-Victorian anything.

Back at the park, Bea’s Supershakes in hand, Madeline asked, “What’s on the agenda for tomorrow?”

“More of the same, I guess. But I really need to track down Brandi’s photo. It may be nothing but then it may be the linchpin to the entire case. What about you?”

“I’m going out to the government site again. Gonna meet with a couple of developers. Just to get estimates. Should be back around five-ish. Should I meet you at your place? I can work on my special – chicken Kiev.”

“Yeah. But plan on seven for dinner. I wanna look into my past a little.”

The two sat silent for a long time, enjoying each other’s company and their supershakes. Slade was the first to break the silence. “Yesterday, I asked you what your maiden name was but you deflected the question. So, I ask again. Madeline, what was your maiden name?”

“Patterson. I became Madeline Snickter when I married Jack Snickter and became Madeline Patterson again when I divorced him.”

“I suppose I shouldn’t ask this, but why did you change back?”

“Everyone thinks it was because I hated the name of Snickter. But in reality, it was because my ex was an absolute asshole. I hate his guts and his name. How’s that for an ugly statement?”

When Slade just shrugged, she said, “Jack was a salesman for IBM. Gone for long times throughout the Northeast. I heard he was whoring around with several of his female ‘teammates.’ At first, I ignored the rumors. But the night I caught him in bed with one of them – my bed, our bed – I kicked his ass out. In divorce court, my attorney read ‘love letters’ from his girlfriends. Six. One of them agreed with him that I was just a cow, good for milking and fucking but nothing else. Of course, I was horribly upset and humiliated. But my best friend forever, Marion Ashton, came through for me. She comforted me as no man could, if you get my drift.”

“Not even me?” Slade asked, his voice tipping up at the end.

“I’m sorry, Slade,” she said quietly. “Not even you. That’s pretty tough for a man to hear, isn’t it?”

“Yeah. I guess so.” Slade was humbled by her frank words. “So, she comforted you through your divorce like you comforted her through hers, right?”

“Yeah.”

“Do you remember what her married name was?”

She laughed. “Ashton! Ellison Ashton is heir to the Ashton oil fortune. It was a pretty amicable parting. His father had put him in charge of their Southeast Asian corporations. He moved to Bangkok and she decided to stay here. For her to continue to receive largess from the Ashton family, she agreed to keep the Ashton name.”

“So… What was her maiden name?”

She furrowed her brows for a long moment. “Y’know, Slade, I think I know but I just can’t remember right at this sec.”

“Maybe it’ll come to you during one of our passionate sessions!” he said, tweaking her breast.

“You do know her father was a pretty good mystery writer, don’t you?”

“Yeah. Marion gave me one of his novels. Something about subway murders. I can’t remember his pseudonym.”

“Eddie Topper.”

“Yeah, that’s it. How come you remember that?”

She laughed. “’Cause when Marion and I were at Purdue, her stepbrother… You do know that she has an older stepbrother and stepsister, don’t you?”

“Yeah. I remember her telling me that. Go on.”

“Anyway, her stepbrother Tobias Topper, visited her over a party weekend. I was really smitten with him. He is tall, maybe six-four. And he was muscular, athletic. He had played for Michigan. Offensive guard or something.”

“Do you know where he is now?”

“Sure. He teaches math at a small college in the Hampton Roads area. Why?”

“Just trying to keep track of the players. So, let me get this straight. Madeline’s maiden name is really Topper, right?”

“Wrong. Madeline was born after Darlene had divorced Topper and married her father. Her father, as a joke, took the pseudonym of Eddie Topper as a jab to her ex. She said that whenever he did a book signing, he’d always wear a cheap top hat. A topper. Get it?”

“Yeah, I get it. So, again, Madeline, what is Marion’s maiden name?”

“You’re gonna need to wait for that passionate sex, buster!” she laughed.

“Okay, I guess. Now to the sixty-four dollar question: Do you know how to get ahold of Tobias Topper, math teacher at some Hampton Roads college?”

“I can find out. First thing in the morning.”

* * *
“Slade? Slade! Wake up! Wake up!” she shook him, hard. “I just remembered! It’s Dawson! And her father’s name was Dave. David and Darlene Dawson! Not Darla, Darlene! They were on Hog Island, Slade! Wake up!”

* * *
The two were sitting at the kitchenette table, wrapped in their robes against the room chill, drinking coffee, and trying to wake up. It was after five but still dark. The lamp next to Slade’s lounger provided the only light in the room. Over and over, he asked her whether she was sure that Marion’s maiden name was Dawson. And over and over, she vehemently said yes.

“Y’know, Madeline…” Sladed sighed, scratching his head. “I think I should pursue my thoughts about Marion’s half-brother.”

“You haven’t told me what you’re after.”

“Marion told me that her father was a writer.”

“Yeah. His oeuvre consisted of at least a dozen mystery novels, an anthology of short stories, some papers on something called derivatives…”

“Does Marion have a complete collection of his work?”

“I doubt it. After he died, there was a dispute among the children over the long-term care of their mother. It was decided to put the house up for sale, the money of the sale to be used to support her during her dementia. I remember Marion saying that her stepbrother had had the contents of the house shipped to him ‘for safe-keeping.’ Her emphasis. She was unhappy with that but she was outnumbered. By the time she got an attorney involved, the house was empty and for sale.”

“So this guy Tobias has all of his writings?”

“Supposedly. So, instead of tracking him down to determine if his mother and stepfather had been on the island, I think I would track him down to learn… What?”

“How about this for a nutty idea? I want to see if David Dawson, prolific writer, kept any notes while they were on the island.”

“You mean, like a diary?”

“Precisely.” His face morphed into a frown. After a long minute of staring into his now-empty coffee cup, he said, very quietly, “Y’know, Madeline… I think I’ve already spoken to Mister Topper. A couple of times.”

“What? When?”

“A while back, I was vetting the people that Professor Lightner had screened for me. While I was doing so, I had a call... Just a minute.” Slade uncovered his leather notebook and flipped a few pages. “Aha. From Mister Elder Wise. He told me that his aunt and uncle were David and Darla Dawson, that they lived on Staten Island, and that they had been on Hog Island – he called it Paradise Island – during the second week of September of ’38. When I asked for more information, he hung up.”

“Why did he call?”

“I’m not sure. Let me tell you how I got to the Dawson name. I’d called the Staten Island Borough, asking how I might locate a family named Dawson who had lived on the island in the thirties. The person that I spoke with referred me to the Mayor, or whatever he’s called. After I explained what I was working on, he said he knew the Dawsons personally. Apparently Dave Dawson had done some financial work for him shortly after the war. I asked him if they still lived there. He said that the Missus was demented and in a special nursing home and that David was dead. When I asked him if there were any children, he said that he thought there were three – a boy and two girls. But he had no information where they were.”

“So, how did this Mister Wise find out about your conversation with the Mayor?”

“Probably the Mayor contacted him regarding my phone call.”

“But he wouldn’t confirm that or give you his phone number or information on his aunt and uncle. Odd. What else did he say?”

“Not a whole lot.”

“We don’t know whether the aunt was his mother’s or his father’s sister, do we?”

“No. But there was a second phone call.” He leafed through his notebook again. Yeah, here it is. He knew about Rodriguez and his MI-8 connection. He said that Rodriguez was probably tracking a couple of German spies – the Eberhardts. He knew all about the Eberhardts. How the man was arrested in Canada and the woman was arrested in New Jersey, I think. The man went to jail, the woman had diplomatic immunity and was exported. When I asked him how come he knew all about these folks, he abruptly hung up.”

“What else did Mister Wise tell you?”

Slade laughed. “He told me that his name was fictitious, that of his right-hand girl, Candy Christmas, was also fictitious, and that any of the numbers I called were no longer in service.” He frowned at her grin. “Why is that funny?”

“Ah, Slade? Hampton Roads is the home of Langley Air Force Base. During the war, it was the testing grounds for antisubmarine detection equipment. You know what group was closely associated with Langley? The Central Intelligence Agency. And what was their objective? Ferreting out espionage units, particularly those that might have come ashore by sea!”

“So…” Slade shook his head. “So, you think that Tobias Topper, the math teacher, may have connections to those folks?”

“May have?” she laughed. “Of course! How else would he have known the stuff that he told you? He’s probably a superspy! The teaching thing is a cover, guy! Get with it! You’re supposed to be the Detective here, y’know.”

“So…” Slade said again, rubbing his forehead. “You think that the guy who called me outa the blue – Mister Elias Wise – is none other than Tobias Topper’s alias? But why did he call with the correct but skewed information and then refuse to identify himself?”

Before she could respond, he asked, “Any more coffee?”

She got him a refill, albeit tepid. He drank it down. “Maybe he’s hiding something?”

“No. Y’know what I think it is? He doesn’t want his stepsister to know that he ratted on her.”

“Whaddaya mean ‘ratted’?”

“Look, Your best friend forever’s been involved up to her titties in this case since the get-go. She had every opportunity to tell me that she was the daughter of the Dawsons. But she didn’t.”

“Did it ever occur to you that she may not know?”

“Huh?”

“Slade, she was born long after her parents had been on the island. Maybe something happened there that kept them from talking about it. To her or to anyone else.”

“’…born long after’? Do you know when she was born?”

“No, but I’ll bet I can find out!”

“How?”
“Purdue Alumni Association. I’ll give them my old ID number, tell them I’m planning on a birthday surprise, and that I want to verify her birthday.”

“But, if you don’t know her birthday…?”

“Silly! I’m gonna use yours. They’ll tell me I’ve got the wrong date and will provide me with the right one.”

“Jesus, Madeline. You make one helluva detective, y’know.”

“Why, thank you sir,” she said, grinning from ear to ear. When Slade reached to pull down her robe, she yelped. “No! I stink and I’m heading for the shower. Alone, thank you very much.”

* * *
“Hello. Is this Tobias Topper? Good. Mister Topper, I believe we’ve spoken before, several weeks ago. I believe you used the alias, Elias Wise. Please do not hang up, sir. I really need some vital information. According to our earlier conversation, your aunt and uncle were at one time or another on Paradise Island. Is that correct? Thank you. I need some additional information that I believe you can provide me. Before I tell you who I am and you hang up on me, let me assure you that I have means of legally extracting the information I need. I understand your silence to mean that you are willing to listen to what I am about to say.”

After a suitable pause for a forthcoming answer, Slade, hearing none, said, “My name is Dollar. You are correct, sir. We did speak earlier. Twice as a matter of fact. Again, sir, I am a Police Detective from Lewiston. As you may be aware, I am working on a long-ago murder case that I believe may have involved your parents. It is my understanding that you were born January 15th, 1934 to Darlene and Elmer Topper. Your sister, Margaret, was born February 20th, 1935, also to Darlene and Elmer Topper. Your parents divorced in April, 1936, and your mother married David Dawson the following year. Is that correct so far, sir? It is? Thank you.

          “It is my understanding that your father died during the Battle of the Bulge. I believe that your stepfather, David Dawson, died just over a year ago. Is that correct also? It is? Thank you again. Is it true that your mother is institutionalized with severe dementia? I am sorry for that. I believe that your father, mother, and step-father only had three children – You, your sister Margaret, and Marion Dawson Ashton, your stepsister. Is that also correct? Again, thank you.

“I understand that after your father’s death, in order to maintain your mother’s care, you, your sister, and your stepsister sold the family home and that you, being the oldest, maintained possession of the household goods. It is my understanding that your stepfather, in his later years, was a prolific writer. Is that correct? Good.

          “Sir, I am still trying to establish time events that occurred on the island the week your mother and her new husband, your stepfather, vacationed there. I would like to rummage through your stepfather’s papers to see if he may have written about their experiences on the island. May I have your permission to do so?”

After a suitable silence at the other end, Slade said, “I assume you are still listening, Mister Topper. If you don’t answer, answer positively, or simply hang up, I will tacitly assume your answer to be no. Please recall, sir, that I am investigating a murder during the time your mother and stepfather were vacationing in proximity to the murder. If you are not willing to help me, I will be forced to obtain a search warrant of all your property and possessions.

“Of course, a formal proceeding of this nature will require you, and possibly your lawyer, to appear in open court. Of necessity, I will need to explain to the judge, in detail, my reasons for wanting the warrant. And because all of the proceedings are oral, anyone in the courtroom, including local reporters, will immediately jump on the information. And, while I am not obliged to extend my courtroom comments to the press, we detectives can sometimes make very effective use of the press to get our message out.

“I have come to believe that, as a math professor in Hampton Roads, you have important covert activities that you may not wish to become overt. Of course, as I just said, there is no assurance that your secret activities can in any way remain as-is during such a formal proceeding. Of course, if you agree to work with me on this issue, none of this will ever surface. You’ll get back all of your stepfather’s writings and you’ll never hear of me again.

“So, Mister Topper or Elder Wise or whatever your alias is today, yes or no? Thumbs up or down? I need your answer now, sir. Right this moment. Do I make myself clear, sir?”

Slade waited, staring out the window at the wharf activity and absentmindedly clicking his pencil on the cover of his notebook. Is this any way to spend a glorious mid-May morning? he thought. He started to reach for his pipe when Tobias Topper, Professor of Mathematical Physics and ardent supporter of The Hampton Roads College Fightin’ Doughboys, coughed and grunted his approval.

“Great. I will contact you with a mutually appropriate time. There will be just two of us and we’ll bring along something to copy documents with. Good-bye until then.”

Slade grinned ear-to-ear as he gently replaced the receiver on its cradle. “God love Miss Moneypenny and Madeline too!”

End of Chapter 57