Chapter 61
Hog Island – 1972
“This is where the plot thickens, Doctor
Bechant,” Slade continued. “From archival stuff we learned about the guy from
his running shoes. We believe that he is Alvin Atkinson. At the time of his
death, he was 25. He was married to Angelica, known professionally as Angel.”
Slade smiled at the frowns his words
generated. “So, now let me tell you about one couple from Paradise Island. The
almost-newly-wed Atkinsons. Briefly, Atkinson was the disenfranchised son of an
up-town millionaire family. He was disowned because he married Angel, a
stripper. Atkinson prided himself as a top-notch amateur photographer. The
owner of Mons Venus in Queens, New York, said that, decades before, the club
was called Saturn. The then owner allowed Atkinson to photograph his girls in
exchange for some appropriate ones for advertising. Atkinson met and
photographed Angel in the buff, in provocative poses. He sold many of her
photos to some European Men’s Magazines. Angel heard he was rich and decided to
marry him, only to learn he’d been disowned. So, we conjecture – again – that
there was no love lost between them on Paradise Island.”
“So, how did he die?” Janus asked, a smirk on
his face.
“Not yet, sir. Let me introduce you to couple
number two - the Bensons. Boyton and Beatrice were also newlyweds. Actually it
was an arranged marriage between two corporations. From my vetting of them, I
would classify them as unloved and unloving nerds. After their week on the
island, they were to embark on their honeymoon by ship to the Mediterranean,
with their final destination being Sicily, where the Bensons had a
manufacturing facility, supplying materiel to the Italian, Greek, and Spanish
militaries. Supposedly Boyton was given the responsibility of running it.”
“Great! Now what happened?” Haggard asked as
he fired up a second cigar.
“From one of my sources, which I shall
identify shortly, I learned that Barbara was terrified of water and only went
on the vacation at the urging of her parents. But Boyton was an avid canoeist,
having qualified as an alternate for the singles 500 meter flatwater race in
Los Angeles in 1932.
Now this is pure conjecture on my part. But I
think it reads well and seems plausible. I think that Boyton got Beatrice into
the canoe and were paddling around the island, just off Paradise Beach when the
boat tipped. She fell into the water. As he tried to get her back into the
canoe, Atkinson arrives to help. And here’s where the story gets a little
bizarre. It’s my guess that Atkinson grabs for the bow rope but it wraps around
his throat. That results in crushing his throat and that little bone in the
neck.”
“Hyoid,” Marion said, writing furiously on
the pages before her.
“Thank you,” he said, not glancing from his
notes. “The boat pulls free of the rope. As Boyton is still struggling to get
Beatrice into the boat, others arrive on the scene. Boyton is out of earshot. Atkinson
is essentially dead but in waist deep water. Some grab the the free end of the
rope, and loop it around Atkinson’s ankles, and drag his body ashore. Probably
to the very spot his bones were found decades later. Dragging his body resulted
in the bone abrasions, broken bones, and the chunk of rope that Marion found on
his remains.”
“Interesting. Okay, who were the people?”
Bechant’s pen was poised over his notebook.
“I’ll get to that shortly, Doc. When Boyton
returns, he’s weeping. Beatrice, his dear wife of only a few weeks, and half
the future of the conglomerate, has been swept to sea and the man who tried to
help save her was dead. At this point we need a head count. The Eberhardts?
They’re probably searching for a way off the island, probably by Rodriguez’
boat. That leaves Angel, Atkinson’s widow, Boyton, the Benson widower, and two
other couples. Let’s talk a moment about them.
“The others are Cameron and Charlotte Carter
and David and Darlene Dawson. The Dawsons? A first marriage for David, a second
for Darlene, who has two children from her previous marriage.
“This may be hard to believe but I am certain
that the Carters were my parents. According to my erstwhile assistant, I was
probably conceived on the island. Darlene also had a child about nine months
after Paradise. Her name was, and is, Marion.”
Simultaneous gasps ensued, with all eyes
focusing on Marion. Bechant asked, “Is that true?” She nodded, keeping her eyes
on the ledger before her.
“Marion has two older step-siblings – Toby
Topper and Margaret Pinkerton. Correct? He said, looking directly at her. She
again nodded, her eyes downcast.
“Perhaps this is an appropriate time to take
a bio-break.”
“Hey, Dollar?” Haggard snorted. “I don’t
think so. Everybody’s gonna hold their pee until I hear whether this story is gonna
have an ending or what?”
“It does, Boss. I believe we – being the
ladies and me - have discovered a most reliable eye-witness to the events I’ve
presented. David Dawson was a well-known author and left behind dozens of
notebooks, logs, diaries, and journals. Marion, your stepbrother, Tobias Topper
- aka Elder Wise and probably a dozen other aliases - allowed me to rummage
through the Dawson artifacts that he purloined from your father’s house. After
hundreds of hours of reading, my volunteer aide and I uncovered this notebook.”
Slade extracted a bound school notebook dated
September 1938. He handed it to Ashton. Without looking at it, she placed it
next to her ledger.
Peculiar, Slade thought. As
he looked down at his notes, he gave a half-smile. After a moment, he looked up
at the group, at their puzzled expressions.
“The notebook is a typical writer’s journal,
chock full of words and phrases. But Mister Dawson also loved to observe
people. And that’s where our interest peaks – beginning after Labor Day, 1938
and continuing to for some time after the Dawson’s stay on Paradise. In your
packet I’ve provided you with copies of Mister Dawson’s journal beginning
around the 9th of September and continuing for a little more than a
week.
“Let me summarize the events this way. According
to Dawson, there was substantial… let us say… hanky-panky on the island.
Hanky-panky that involved three couples – the Atkinsons, the Dawsons, and the
Carters. Yes, my folks were included as were Miss Ashton’s. Again according to
Dawson, Mister Atkinson was somewhat of a gigalo. Although he wasn’t a very big
man, his manner and outstanding good looks apparently attracted women. An
Adonis, Dawson said the women – especially my mother and Marion’s - called him.”
“I object, Dollar. Your insinuations are
vulgar, obscene!” Marion yelled, slamming the journal hard on the table.
“Don’t be too judgmental, Marion. Because you
and I were born only a few days apart, we might very well be kissin’ cousins.
Or even brother and sister,” he snapped. “It seems that the islanders found a
cache of first-class wine and imbibed and imbibed and imbibed some more. And
after that, there was sex. Your father called it a world-class bacchanal.”
Those words hit her like a rock. She dropped
back in her chair, glaring at him. Slowly her expression softened. “I’m sorry,
Slade. It’s just that all of this…”
“…comes as a blow to the gut. Yeah. It hit me
the same way.” Slade pulled out another folder. “According to the local papers,
because the Paradise shuttle was sunk in the storm, the evacuation of the
tourists from Hog Island was helter-skelter. As a result, there is no record of
who was actually on the island just prior to the storm, who was rescued, and
who was missing. What we do know is that Mister and Missus Benson caught their
ship to Italy in Miami exactly three days later.”
“Wait!” Bechant said. “I thought that…”
“You thought correctly, Doc.” Slade
interrupted. He pulled a newspaper page from yet another folder and held it up.
“You are looking at a photograph of Mister and Missus Benson at a New Year’s
Eve cocktail party in Salermo. The date? December 31st, 1938. If you
look in your folder at that page and at the two inset photographs - the one on
the left being that of Angel, the stripper, and the one on the right being
Beatrice Barbato Benson nee Barone – it is apparent that the new Missus Benson
who arrived on the island on the arm of Boyton Benson at Tiki Town, Paradise
Island on the 10th of September was not the Missus Benson who was at
the party in Italy a little over three months later.”
“Wait, Slade…” Haggard’s bravado had melted
into a serious ponder. “Are you saying that the stripper was really Missus
Benson?”
“No, boss. The real Missus Benson was in the
boat that disappeared from Hog Island only to be beached on the neighboring
barrier island. Keep in mind, Atkinson had lost his inheritance but Boyton
still had his. Atkinson was dead and apparently so was Beatrice. Angel
immediately realized that milquetoast Boyton was her next money source. She
convinced him to leave with her. She found Beatrice’s passport and the ship
line tickets and the two sailed away to Italy to live happily everafter, or at
least happily for her. Ergo, the two Missus Bensons.
“You mean nobody objected to that?” Ashton
asked. “And nobody reported the death of Atkinson and that Beatrice was
missing?”
“The cop was dead, the agent was dead, the
Germans had - for whatever reason - apparently fled. The storm scattered
everybody, and I guess it was prudent for everybody to find their own way home.
Marion’s father wrote weeks later, around the end of September, 1938, that six
people survived the storm. He and his wife found each other in Bridgeport. They
took a train to Manhattan where they were again met by the storm, this time
destroying their home on Staten Island.”
And where were your parents all this time?”
Marion asked snidely.
“Dunno. But my gramma told me that after the
Hurricane, we moved to New Jersey. My dad opened a law office in Newark. Mom
and dad were killed on the Jersey Turnpike when I was 5 or 6.”
“Anyway, back to your father. He spent several
months researching the Paradise Island issue but never learned of the fate of
the others. Nor did anyone bother to ask. No one in authority, no one from the
hosting company, and certainly no curious news reporters. His last entry was after
midnight on the 4th of July, 1939.”
“What was that entry?” Haggard said. He was
now at full attention, unmindful that his cigar had extinguished itself at the
edge of the conference table.
“I’m glad you asked,” Slade smiled. He pulled
another page from his folder and read:
Anyway, I hear someone beginning the 4th
early. After all, it is a little after 2 in the morning. Firecrackers. War on
the horizon. With two kids and a third on the way, I should be at least 3A or
something. But you never know. Heard recently that German U-boats were sighted
off Atlantic coast.
Wonder if we’re safe here on Staten Island. Then again,
why would anyone want to invade a 60 square mile island with fewer than 160,000
people and probably ten times that many hogs, chickens, cows, and sheep, when
they can get all of Manhattan for just a few additional minutes boat ride.
And what about the gulf. Wonder about Paradise Island and
that idiot Golden’s Tiki Town. Was it an outpost for German espionage? And I
wonder about Darlene’s pregnancy too. Pediatrician guesses she conceived about
that week. Bacchanalia?
“Oh, and chief? Here’s something for your
archives.” Slade reached into his bag, extracted something, and rolled them across
the table. “The two missing shell casings. Courtesy of Marion’s father.”
End of Chapter 61
End of Hog Island Mysteries